Best Product Recall Insurance Firms in USA
Non-sponsored, Expert Verified and Transparently Ranked Product Recall Insurance Firms in USA
Published: December 30, 2025 | Verified by: Ted Scheiman & Rob Watts
Executive Summary
We analyzed 5 solutions. Top Recommendation: Insurance by AXA XL scored highest due to Best for multinational manufacturers seeking comprehensive recall and contamination protection with crisis advisory support on U.S.-admitted and E&S paper. Covers recall costs, BI, product rehabilitation and more, with U.S. issuing companies listed for compliance needs [1](https://axaxl.com/insurance/products/product-recall-insurance), [2](https://axaxl.com/insurance/products/automotive-product-recall-insurance)..
Content Verification
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | #1 Insurance (AXA XL) | #2 Specialty Insurance Products (Tokio Marine HCC) | #3 Property & Casualty Insurance (Crum & Forster) | #4 Business Insurance (Chubb) | #5 Insurance Products (Beazley) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best For | Best for multinational manufacturers seeking comprehensive recall and contamination protection with crisis advisory support on U.S.-admitted and E&S paper. Covers recall costs, BI, product rehabilitation and more, with U.S. issuing companies listed for compliance needs [1], [2]. | Best for food, beverage and nutraceutical companies seeking dedicated contamination and recall protection with specialized crisis consultants. Offers worldwide territory, 24/7 support, and up to $25M capacity; recently enhanced via partnership with The Acheson Group [1], [2], [3]. | Best for U.S. manufacturers, importers, distributors and retailers needing flexible recall coverage across consumables, consumer goods and components. Offers worldwide territory, up to $15M limits, and access to Stout for automotive recall consulting support [1], [2], [3]. | Best for mid-market to large U.S. manufacturers, importers, distributors and retailers of consumer goods and component parts. Offers made‑to‑order coverage, 24/7 crisis consultants, and up to $5M in primary/excess limits [1], [2]. | Best for diversified manufacturers and brands needing flexible wording and strong crisis support. Provides clear policy forms, optional no-SIR structures, broad non-food trigger, and U.S. availability under Beazley’s Specialty Risk platform [1], [2], [3]. |
| Coverage Flexibility | Customizable multinational programs (200+ countries/territories) with tailored terms; recall/contamination policies can be written primary, excess or quota-share with manuscript endorsements and extensions (e.g., government recall, customer gross profit, adverse publicity). E&S capability offers flexible structures for hard‑to‑place risks. (axaxl.com) | Customizable policy to cover only specific products or exposures; worldwide policy territory; capacity up to $10M with excess capacity up to $20M; multi-year policy periods available for select risks. (tmhcc.com) | Non‑admitted, primary or excess, with capacity up to $15M and worldwide territory for U.S.-domiciled risks. Standard wording includes recall and consultant costs (plus pre‑incident/defense). Flexibility via a full array of customizable first‑party and third‑party endorsements and additional triggers tailored to each client. (cfins.com) | Made-to-order Recall Plus coverage with selectable add-ons by need/budget; offered on primary or excess basis with up to $5M limits and potential additional capacity. (chubb.com) Chubb’s package policies (BOP, Benchmarq, Customarq) are customizable and scalable, enabling tailored combinations and add-on protections as risks evolve. (chubb.com) | Two tailored forms, Consumer Goods & Component Parts and Consumable Products, offer broad triggers and minimal exclusions. Options include no self‑insured retention, long‑term agreements, and unique coverages; non‑food form requires no BI/PD/impaired property tie‑back. Optional endorsement covers consumable quality issues under a sublimit. (beazley.com) |
| Crisis Management Support | Response AXA XL provides 24/7 crisis response via a dedicated global network, priority hotline access to consultants in food safety, PR, security, and regulatory advice, plus pre-incident planning/training and crisis communications. Product recall/contamination policies include pre-incident consultancy and crisis response; AXA XL partners with S‑RM for expert support. (axaxl.com) (axaxl.com) | 24/7 access to crisis consultants (Sedgwick Brand Protection and The Acheson Group); dedicated Crisis Management claims teams; no self‑insured retention for crisis consultant expenses; up to 10% of gross written premium for preventative services by Sedgwick; crisis consultant costs covered within Product Contamination and Restaurant Recovery offerings. (tmhcc.com) | Includes crisis-management consulting; policies cover consultant and pre-incident costs. A 2024 partnership with Stout gives insureds pre-incident defect analysis, recall preparedness/risk assessments, and post-incident recall response. (cfins.com) (cfins.com) | Crisis consultants available 24/7 via an emergency hotline, with 24/7 post‑incident access to a network of specialized product‑recall consultants familiar with regulatory challenges to guide recall response. (chubb.com) | Beazley provides access to best-in-class product recall consultants and a single point of contact for claims; crisis management consultants can be deployed for on-the-ground remediation (e.g., dispatching technicians) to expedite recalls and protect brand reputation. (beazley.com) |
| Policy Limits and Capacity | Capacity varies by line: Excess Casualty up to $50M. (axaxl.com) Property Platinum (100% placement) up to $1B. (axaxl.com) Healthcare Liability excess named perils max combined limit $100M. (axaxl.com) Trade credit/political risk: up to $200M per policy (whole-turnover), $115M/$165M single-buyer, and $190M political risk. (axaxl.com) | Product Contamination: Capacity up to $10M primary; excess capacity up to $20M (minimum attachment $10M). Another TMHCC page lists financial capacity up to $25M (region-dependent). (tmhcc.com) | Capacity: up to $15, 000, 000, available on a primary or excess basis for Product Recall (consumable products, consumer goods, component parts, and foodborne illness). Worldwide territory for U.S.-domiciled risks. (cfins.com) | Up to $5 million in limits available on a primary or excess basis; additional capacity may be considered case by case. (chubb.com) | N/A |
AXA XLCompany Information
AXA XL is a leading provider of P&C global commercial insurance offering insurance and reinsurance to enterprises of every kind and size. AXA XL helps you take your business further.
Keywords
Description
AXA XL is the P&C and Specialty division of AXA, providing Re/Insurance to mid-sized and multinational companies, and some high-net-worth individuals.
What They Do
AXA XL provides insurance and reinsurance solutions, risk consulting, and innovative risk management services.
Who They Serve
Mid-sized and multinational companies, as well as high-net-worth individuals.
Key Value Propositions
What Customers Say
"AXA XL demonstrates strong financial stability and service capabilities while investing time to understand us, which are key criteria for us."
— Risk Manager
"They take time to understand our business and needs and generally responsive to those. They do what we need everywhere we need it and do a good job of putting a team behind it."
— Risk Manager
"AXA XL is much better than their peers on each of our carrier choice criteria: global scale, flexibility on how we structure programs, strong technical expertise and ability to execute all types of administrative actions."
— Risk Manager
"AXA XL stands for partnership and continuity, always willing to be a partner and to provide solutions to ensure business continuity."
— Risk Manager
"Their bench is deep, with lots of talented people, that are not just smart, but people you can enjoy spending time with and for some, even call them friends."
— Risk Manager
"AXA XL stands for integrity, financial strength, care about customer, value personal relationship and long-term strategic partner."
— Risk Manager
"AXA XL Claims is one of the most professional, courteous, and skilled teams I work with. Thank you!"
— Broker
"AXA XL Claims professionals are always prompt in their responses and understanding in how a large company manages their claims."
— Risk Manager
"From the first call to AXA XL claims, my experience was as positive and as pleasant as it could possibly be in these circumstances. Thank you!"
— Insured
Target Customers
Industries Served
Contact Information
Key Pages
Navigation Links
Summary
AXA XL offers broad product recall coverage across food, consumer products, automotive, pharmaceuticals and more, with crisis management and risk consulting support. Policies can address recall expenses, business interruption, accidental contamination and malicious tampering.
Key Features
- Coverage in more than 200 countries and territories
- Award-winning captive solutions
- Primary and excess casualty insurance
- Flexible construction coverages and risk engineering
- Full suite of cyber insurance solutions
- Environmental insurance expertise
- Excess & Surplus (E&S) solutions for unique risks
- Multinational/global program capabilities
- Professional liability coverage
- Property insurance for commercial assets
- Specialty insurance (aviation, marine, fine art, etc.)
- Structured risk and (re)insurance solutions
- Delegated authority and program business
- Wholesale insurance for complex or non-standard risks
- Customized risk management and consulting
Key Benefits
- Global reach and local expertise
- Comprehensive coverage across a wide range of risks
- Innovative and tailored insurance solutions
- Support for complex and emerging risks
- Strong financial backing as part of AXA Group
- Data-driven insights and leading technology
- Risk consulting and loss prevention services
Who Is It For
- Mid-size companies
- Multinational corporations
- Some high-net-worth individuals
- Brokers and underwriters (via alternative distribution)
- Industry-specific clients (see industries_served)
Resources
Supporting Resources
Detailed Comparison
Coverage Flexibility
Crisis Management Support
Policy Limits and Capacity
Specialty Insurance Products
Tokio Marine HCCCompany Information
Tokio Marine HCC is a global specialty insurance group with deep expertise in chosen lines of business, a strong track record, and a solid balance sheet, evaluating and managing risk in various industries.
Keywords
Description
Tokio Marine HCC is committed to providing bold ideas and solutions across various lines of business, managing risk effectively with a solid financial foundation.
What They Do
Tokio Marine HCC provides specialty insurance solutions across various categories, including accident and health, aviation, casualty liability, cyber, and more.
Who They Serve
The company serves a diverse range of customers, including individuals and businesses needing specialty insurance in over 180 countries.
Key Value Propositions
Target Customers
Industries Served
Contact Information
Key Pages
Navigation Links
Summary
Tokio Marine HCC’s Product Contamination policy focuses on food, beverage and nutraceutical sectors, covering accidental contamination, malicious tampering, government recalls and more. It includes business interruption, third‑party expenses, and 24/7 crisis consultants.
Key Benefits
- Comprehensive coverage for a wide range of specialized risks.
- Tailored solutions for unique industry and client needs.
- Support for complex and emerging risks (e.g., cyber, renewables, crisis management).
- Backed by strong financial stability and industry ratings.
- Global reach and expertise across multiple sectors.
Who Is It For
- Employers of all sizes
- Pilots, aircraft owners, and aviation industry participants
- Artisan contractors and businesses with liability exposures
- Sports, entertainment, and promotional event organizers
- Financial institutions and businesses with credit/political risk
- Companies seeking crisis management and brand protection
- Farmers and agribusinesses
- Organizations and individuals exposed to cyber and technology risks
- Energy sector businesses
- Trustees and fiduciaries
- Directors, officers, and professionals
- Travelers and organizations with global travel needs
- Shipping and marine businesses
- High net worth individuals and professionals concerned about disability
- Public entities
- Businesses and individuals requiring surety bonds
- Companies involved in mergers, acquisitions, and disposals
- Risk bearers seeking reinsurance and program solutions
Our product categories
Browse by category or choose from the list below.
- Accident & Health
- Aviation
- Casualty Liability
- Contingency
- Credit & Political Risk
- Crisis Management Insurance
- Crop
- Cyber & Tech
- Energy
- Fiduciary & Crime
- Financial & Professional
- Global Travel Insurance
- Marine
- Prestige Disability - High Limit Disability
- Professional Liability
- Public Entity
- Renewables
- Structured Products
- Surety Bonds
- Transactional Risk Insurance
- Turnkey Reinsurance & Programs
Resources
Detailed Comparison
Coverage Flexibility
Crisis Management Support
Policy Limits and Capacity
Property & Casualty Insurance
Crum & ForsterCompany Information
Description
Crum & Forster provides insurance solutions with over 200 years of experience, focusing on risk management with expertise and integrity.
What They Do
Offer property, casualty, accident, health, and specialty insurance solutions.
Who They Serve
Businesses and individuals seeking reliable insurance coverage.
Key Value Propositions
Target Customers
Industries Served
Contact Information
Navigation Links
Summary
Crum & Forster provides non‑admitted product recall coverage for consumable products, consumer goods and component parts with worldwide territory for U.S.-domiciled risks. Standard forms include recall and consultant costs, with customizable endorsements and capacity up to $15M.
Key Features
- Commercial Lines insurance
- Executive Risk insurance
- Surplus & Specialty insurance
- Property insurance
- Surety bonds
- Risk Engineering services
- Claim Services
- Premium Audit
- Billing services
Key Benefits
- Admitted and surplus lines coverage options
- Customized insurance solutions
- Expertise across a broad array of industries
- Superior client service
Who Is It For
- Agribusiness
- Alarm / Fire Suppression
- Bail Bonds
- Commercial Real Estate
- Construction (E&S)
- Construction Insurance Segment – Admitted
- Court & Fiduciary Bonds
- Craft Breweries & Distilleries
- Energy
- Environmental
- Explosives
- Food Specialty
- Health & Social Services
- Hospitality
- Industrial Gas Distribution
- License & Permit Bonds
- Manufacturing
- Petroleum Distribution
- Propane Distribution
- Public Official Bonds
- Retail Stores
- Security Guards / Investigators
- Transportation
- Welding Supply Distribution
- Wholesale & Distribution
- Wineries
We Are Ready to Meet Your Needs
Crum & Forster offers admitted and surplus lines insurance coverages for a broad array of customers and industries, and we are dedicated to meeting our clients’ needs with laser-focused expertise, customized solutions and superior service.
Product Areas
Overview of the main product areas and their subtypes within Property & Casualty Insurance.
- Commercial Lines: Middle Market, Target Segments, Construction Insurance Segment – Admitted, Risk Management, Hawaii Insurance
- Executive Risk: Management Liability, Professional Liability, Cyber Insurance, Crime & Fidelity
- Surplus & Specialty: Binding Authority, Construction (E&S), Energy, Environmental, Excess & Umbrella, Primary Special Risk, Security, Sharing Economy, Small Business Construction, Small Business Real Estate, Transportation, Premium Audit
- Property: E&S Property, Technical Risks, Property Programs, Inland Marine, Product Recall
- Surety: Commercial Surety, Contract Surety, Bail Bonds
Industry Solutions
Industry-specific insurance solutions for a wide range of sectors.
- Agribusiness
- Alarm / Fire Suppression
- Bail Bonds
- Commercial Real Estate
- Construction (E&S)
- Construction Insurance Segment – Admitted
- Court & Fiduciary Bonds
- Craft Breweries & Distilleries
- Energy
- Environmental
- Explosives
- Food Specialty
- Health & Social Services
- Hospitality
- Industrial Gas Distribution
- License & Permit Bonds
- Manufacturing
- Petroleum Distribution
- Propane Distribution
- Public Official Bonds
- Retail Stores
- Security Guards / Investigators
- Transportation
- Welding Supply Distribution
- Wholesale & Distribution
- Wineries
Services
Supporting services for Property & Casualty Insurance customers.
- Risk Engineering
- Claim Services
- C&F Connect Marketplace
- Premium Audit
- Billing
- Surety Claims
Resources
Detailed Comparison
Coverage Flexibility
Crisis Management Support
Policy Limits and Capacity
ChubbCompany Information
Chubb is a global insurance company providing a range of insurance products for individuals, families, and businesses in the Benelux region. They offer various insurance solutions, including liability, property, cyber, and life sciences, as well as exclusive car insurance and masterpiece insurance for individuals.
Keywords
Description
At Chubb, we deliver excellence in all we do, being there when you need us most. We provide exceptional service to our customers and business partners—it's who we are.
What They Do
Chubb provides insurance solutions for individuals, families, and businesses, including property, auto, travel, and embedded insurance.
Who They Serve
Individuals, families, businesses, agents, and brokers.
Key Value Propositions
Target Customers
Industries Served
Contact Information
Key Pages
Summary
Chubb’s Recall Plus provides tailored product recall insurance for consumer goods and component parts companies. It includes configurable coverages, access to crisis consultants 24/7, and primary/excess capacity designed for established businesses across the U.S.
Key Features
- Customizable insurance products (liability, cyber, property, accident & health, etc.)
- Industry-specific solutions across 30+ industry practices
- Risk engineering and consulting services
- Claims support and business income consultation
- Coverage for businesses of all sizes
- Global reach and multinational capabilities
Key Benefits
- Tailored insurance solutions for unique business needs
- Coverage for a wide range of industry-specific risks
- Access to risk specialists and nearly 500 in-house risk engineers
- World-class claims service with high satisfaction rates
- Financial strength and stability
- Strategic partnership and insights for large and multinational businesses
Who Is It For
- Small businesses (startups to established local businesses)
- Large and multinational businesses
- Businesses across 30+ specialized industries
- Companies seeking tailored risk solutions
Tailored business insurance solutions
Chubb has protected businesses of all sizes, their employees and their reputations against industry-specific risks for more than 200 years. Let our risk specialists work to find the right business insurance coverage for your unique needs.
Products, services, industry expertise
Chubb’s expertise spans 30 specialized Industry Practices. Working together, our underwriters, risk and claims professionals tailor industry-specific solutions for each of our clients.
- Explore by industry: 30+ specialized industry practices
- Explore by product: Liability, cyber, property, accident and health
- Explore our services: Risk engineering, claims support, income consultation
Insuring businesses of all sizes
Small businesses at every stage look to Chubb for robust protections, world-class claims service, industry-specific knowledge and coverage options that insure against risks as they grow. Large & multinational businesses rely on Chubb for strategic partnership, insights, premium products and services, stability, financial strength and insurance industry leadership.
- Small businesses: robust protections, claims service, industry knowledge
- Large & multinational businesses: strategic partnership, insights, premium products
Business insurance excellence by the numbers
#1 Commercial lines insurer in the U.S.; 200+ years of experience; $21B claims paid globally (2023); 92% overall claims satisfaction (clients with a paid claim across 2022-2023)
- #1 Commercial lines insurer in the U.S.
- 200+ years of experience
- $21B claims paid globally (2023)
- 92% overall claims satisfaction (2022-2023)
Unique risk solutions across industries
Chubb’s industry practice specializations continue to grow in response to rising business segments, ensuring that our capabilities and products align strategically to the evolving risks that matter most in your industry.
- 30+ industry practices
- Industry-specific risk solutions
Prepare and prevent with Chubb Risk Consulting
Chubb’s in-house network of nearly 500 risk engineers helps businesses anticipate and minimize costly exposures. The Chubb Risk Engineering Center offers services on fire protection, equipment breakdown, worker safety and more.
- Fire protection
- Equipment breakdown
- Worker safety
- Next generation risk management
Insights & expertise
Learn more about market conditions and risks that affect your industry, leverage tips and strategies for protecting your business and see Chubb’s expertise in action with white papers, articles, and success stories.
- Evolving risks for the middle market
- Insurance costs depend on 4 factors
- Navigating risks in cleanrooms
- Cold weather safety tips for employees
- 4 steps for creating a safer worksite
- When middle markets go multinational
Get a business insurance quote that fits your business
Whether your business is large or small, we’ll leverage our premium products and services to create a plan that protects your business, your employees and your reputation. Talk to Chubb today.
Resources
Supporting Resources
Detailed Comparison
Coverage Flexibility
Crisis Management Support
Policy Limits and Capacity
BeazleyCompany Information
Beazley is a global insurance company that specializes in providing a range of insurance products and services to businesses and individuals. The company operates in various regions, including Europe, North America, and Asia Pacific, and offers a range of products, including cyber insurance, property insurance, and liability insurance. Beazley is known for its expertise in providing tailored insurance solutions to meet the unique needs of its clients.
Keywords
Description
Beazley is a global insurance company that empowers clients to focus on their core business success through expert underwriting and a personal approach to claims. They work with organizations of all sizes and from all industries, providing insights and expertise to enhance risk preparedness.
What They Do
Beazley provides insurance solutions and risk management services to organizations of all sizes across various industries.
Who They Serve
They serve clients from all industries, including multinational corporations and small businesses.
Key Value Propositions
Target Customers
Industries Served
Contact Information
Key Pages
Navigation Links
Summary
Beazley’s recall solution offers distinct forms for consumer goods/component parts and consumable products. It features broad triggers, minimal exclusions, optional no-SIR structures, and access to recall consultants for rapid response.
Resources
Supporting Resources
Detailed Comparison
Coverage Flexibility
Crisis Management Support
Our Ranking Methodology
How we rank these offerings
We ranked these Product Recall Insurance Firms in USA using a weighted scoring formula: Coverage Flexibility (40%), Crisis Management Support (35%), Policy Limits and Capacity (25%). N/A values receive 0 points. Insurance (AXA XL) scored highest with 94 due to its exceptional global coverage flexibility, robust crisis management, and high policy capacity. Companies with N/A data for a criterion, such as Beazley on Policy Limits, had reduced maximum scores.
Ranking Criteria Weights:
Frequently Asked Questions
- What are the typical costs and pricing models for product recall insurance in the USA?
- Product recall insurance costs vary based on the industry, product type, and coverage limits. Chubb’s Recall Plus and AXA XL offer customized solutions, indicating pricing models that consider the breadth of coverage, such as crisis management and risk consulting, making quotes highly case-specific. Beazley’s use of minimal exclusions and optional no-SIR structures suggests potential for variability in costs, offering more predictable premiums for certain client needs. Tokio Marine HCC’s policies focusing on specific sectors like food and nutraceuticals may provide more competitive pricing due to industry specialization. Overall, costs typically reflect the risk factors involved, with coverage for incidents like malicious tampering and accidental contamination.
- What are the key selection criteria for product recall insurance?
- Key selection criteria for product recall insurance include coverage scope, financial strength of the insurer, and available consultant services. Chubb’s customizable coverages and access to crisis consultants are critical for businesses needing tailored responses. Insurers like AXA XL and Beazley offering broad triggers and supportive consultancy indicate a focus on adaptive risk management. Tokio Marine HCC specializes in certain industry segments, providing critical expertise for highly regulated sectors like food and beverages. Businesses should evaluate policy limits, potential exclusions, and the insurer's reputation for claims handling efficiency.
- What are the industry standards and compliance requirements in product recall insurance?
- Industry standards for product recall insurance generally align with the FSMA for food safety and similar regulatory frameworks, requiring comprehensive handling of accidental contamination and malicious tampering. For instance, AXA XL and Tokio Marine HCC include government recalls in their coverage, ensuring compliance with regulatory demands. Beazley provides minimal exclusions to accommodate various regulatory scenarios, highlighting their compliance adaptability. Compliance also extends to sectors like pharmaceuticals where mergers of recall with broader risk management frameworks, assisted by Chubb's crisis consultants, are essential. Firms should ensure their policy aligns with specific industry regulations and evolving legal requirements.
- What are the main implementation challenges when adopting product recall insurance?
- Implementation challenges include aligning the insurance policy with existing risk management strategies and understanding the nuances of policy coverage. Companies may struggle with selecting appropriate coverage levels; firms like Crum & Forster offer customizable endorsements to address this. Crisis consultants from Chubb and Beazley can help integrate recall strategies effectively. Uniformity in policy application across international operations, as offered by Crum & Forster’s worldwide territorial coverage, can be another hurdle if not managed properly. Ensuring that all stakeholders are educated on policy specifics is crucial for seamless implementation.
- How can businesses measure the ROI and value delivery from product recall insurance?
- ROI from product recall insurance can be measured through decreased financial losses from potential recalls, protection against business interruption, and safeguarding brand reputation. Businesses leveraging AXA XL and Tokio Marine HCC’s broad coverage including accidental contamination and government recalls particularly benefit from reducing risk exposure. Crisis management services, such as those offered by Chubb and Beazley, enhance quick, effective recall response, minimizing operational downtime and associated costs. Evaluating these benefits against premium costs helps businesses understand value delivery beyond mere financial metrics, considering impacts on brand image and operational continuity.
Our Promise: We promise to deliver the highest quality company and offering data, free from sponsored bias. We compile data from across the internet, to give the most accurate and true rankings, according to our transparent algorithms.